Hawaiian Airlines vs. Alaska Airlines: Benefits of Flying with Alaska Airlines

Hawaiian Airlines vs. Alaska Airlines: When it comes to traveling to and from the Hawaiian Islands or other destinations on the West Coast, two prominent airlines stand out: Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines. Both airlines offer extensive routes, premium services, and a loyal customer base. However, choosing the best airline depends on several factors, such as the type of traveler you are, your preferred in-flight experience, and your destination.

This post dives deep into the key differences and similarities between Hawaiian and Alaska Airlines, helping you decide which is the best fit for your next trip.

Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines

Hawaiian Airlines is Hawaii’s largest and longest-serving airline, established in 1929. Known for its island hospitality and consistent on-time performance, Hawaiian Airlines primarily connects Hawaii with destinations in the mainland United States, Asia, and the South Pacific.

Alaska Airlines was founded in 1932 and has grown to become one of the largest airlines in the U.S. with a robust network that includes flights to Hawaii, the Pacific Northwest, and numerous destinations throughout the U.S., Canada, and Mexico. The airline is well-known for its customer service, loyalty program, and innovative approach to in-flight experiences.

Route Networks: Where Do They Fly?

One of the primary differences between Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines is their route networks.

• Hawaiian Airlines Routes:
  • Specializes in flights between the U.S. mainland and Hawaii, with a strong focus on direct routes to major cities like Los Angeles, New York, and Las Vegas.
  • International routes include destinations in Japan, South Korea, Australia, and New Zealand.
  • Inter-island flights within Hawaii make it easy for travelers to hop between islands, such as Maui, Oahu, and Kauai.
• Alaska Airlines Routes:
  • Alaska Airlines also offers a variety of flights to and from Hawaii, with a focus on West Coast hubs such as Seattle, Portland, and Los Angeles.
  • Alaska Airlines operates a wider network across the mainland U.S., Alaska, Canada, Mexico, and even parts of Central America.
  • Horizon Air, a regional partner, operates shorter routes across the West Coast, giving passengers access to smaller airports.

Airline	Main Hub Cities	Destinations
Hawaiian Airlines	Honolulu (HNL), Kahului (OGG)	Hawaii, U.S. Mainland, Asia-Pacific
Alaska Airlines	Seattle (SEA), Anchorage (ANC)	U.S., Hawaii, Canada, Mexico

In-Flight Experience: Comfort and Entertainment

Both airlines prioritize comfort and entertainment, but there are some key differences that may sway your choice depending on what you’re looking for in your flight experience.

• Hawaiian Airlines:
  • Known for its “Hawaii-inspired” ambiance, Hawaiian Airlines offers island-themed meals, snacks, and beverages.
  • Passengers receive a taste of the islands with locally sourced ingredients, such as Hawaiian-style teriyaki chicken or paniolo chili.
  • In-flight entertainment includes a selection of movies, TV shows, and Hawaiian cultural programming, though you may need to bring your own device to access the content.
  • Hawaiian Airlines offers Extra Comfort seats, which provide additional legroom and priority boarding.
• Alaska Airlines:
  • Alaska Airlines has a strong reputation for service, offering upgraded meals and beverages, often featuring partnerships with local Pacific Northwest brands.
  • Alaska Beyond Entertainment offers free movies and TV shows, available on passengers’ own devices. They also offer Wi-Fi, with packages available for purchase.
  • Premium Class seating provides extra legroom and free drinks, plus early boarding for those looking for a more comfortable experience.

Frequent Flyer Programs: HawaiianMiles vs. Mileage Plan

Frequent travelers will be interested in the loyalty programs offered by each airline.

• Hawaiian Airlines – HawaiianMiles:
  • HawaiianMiles members earn miles for every flight they take, as well as through partner brands.
  • Miles can be redeemed for free flights, hotel stays, and car rentals.
  • Elite members receive benefits like priority boarding, free seat upgrades, and lounge access.
• Alaska Airlines – Mileage Plan:
  • Mileage Plan is often regarded as one of the most generous frequent flyer programs, offering miles based on distance flown rather than ticket price.
  • Alaska’s partnership with Oneworld and other airlines means members can earn and redeem miles with partner airlines like American Airlines, British Airways, and Qatar Airways.
  • Members also enjoy benefits like free checked bags, priority boarding, and access to Alaska Lounges.

Key Benefits of Flying with Hawaiian Airlines

• Hawaiian Vibe: Flying with Hawaiian Airlines gives passengers a true island experience, from the moment they step on board. The island-inspired décor, meals, and hospitality help travelers immerse themselves in Hawaiian culture.
• On-Time Performance: Hawaiian Airlines consistently ranks among the most on-time airlines in the U.S., making it a great choice if punctuality is your top priority.
• Direct Flights to Hawaii: If you’re heading to Hawaii from the mainland, Hawaiian Airlines offers non-stop flights from multiple cities, reducing the need for layovers.

Key Benefits of Flying with Alaska Airlines

• Broad Domestic and International Network: Alaska Airlines’ expansive route network is ideal for travelers who frequently fly between Hawaii and the mainland or other international destinations.
• Mileage Plan Perks: Alaska Airlines offers one of the best frequent flyer programs, allowing travelers to earn valuable miles with a wide range of partners.
• Customer Satisfaction: Alaska Airlines consistently scores high in customer satisfaction ratings, with praise for its friendly staff, in-flight services, and overall experience.

Pricing and Baggage Fees

Both Hawaiian and Alaska Airlines are considered premium carriers, but their pricing structures differ, particularly when it comes to baggage.

• Hawaiian Airlines:
  • Passengers are allowed one free carry-on and a personal item.
  • Checked baggage fees apply, typically starting at $30 for the first bag and increasing for additional bags.
  • Frequent flyers and elite members may receive complimentary checked bags based on their status.
• Alaska Airlines:
  • Similar to Hawaiian, Alaska allows one free carry-on and a personal item.
  • Checked bag fees are also $30 for the first bag, but Alaska Airlines offers special discounts for its Alaska Airlines Visa Signature® cardholders, who can check one bag for free.

Airline	Carry-On	Checked Bag (First)	Discount for Frequent Flyers
Hawaiian Airlines	Free	$30	Free bags for elite members
Alaska Airlines	Free	$30	Free for Mileage Plan members, credit cardholders

Conclusion: Which Airline Should You Choose?

When choosing between Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines, the best option depends on your specific needs. If you’re looking for a more immersive Hawaiian experience and are focused on flying directly to or within the islands, Hawaiian Airlines might be the better choice. Its island-themed services and stellar on-time performance give it an edge for travelers heading to Hawaii.

On the other hand, if you’re seeking more route flexibility and a broader frequent flyer program, Alaska Airlines could be the ideal choice. With its strong West Coast presence, extensive network, and a frequent flyer program that stands out, it’s a great option for travelers who want more than just a Hawaii connection.

Both airlines provide excellent service, and your decision will likely come down to your travel priorities, loyalty program preferences, and specific destinations.